Quick Answer: Did Helen Betray The Trojans?

Why didn’t the Trojans give Helen back?

Some of the answers cite the Iliad to show some attempts to avert the city’s destruction, but these were already doomed to fail.

Priam decided not to give Helen back directly, and when Menelaus bested Paris in combat, the gods spirited him away..

Did Helen love Paris?

Helen was already married to King Menelaus of Sparta (a fact Aphrodite neglected to mention), so Paris had to raid Menelaus’s house to steal Helen from him – according to some accounts, she fell in love with Paris and left willingly. … When Paris took her to Troy, Menelaus invoked this oath.

Who killed Helen of Troy?

From one side, we read about the treacherous Helen who simulated Bacchic rites and rejoiced over the carnage of Trojans. On the other hand, there is another Helen, lonely and helpless; desperate to find sanctuary, while Troy is on fire. Stesichorus narrates that both Greeks and Trojans gathered to stone her to death.

What happened to the survivors of Troy?

As for the Trojans, most of the men were killed, and most of the women were taken as captives by the invading Greeks. The rest were taken prisoner and brought back to Greece with Agamemnon and his army.

Why did Achilles call Hector his brother?

He saw Hector as brother, because they shared together his most important values. And he killed him. Achilles could have probably felt like he killed himself, for a reason that might seem absurd from that perspective… That’s why the tears and that’s why he said “we’ll meet soon my brother”.

Who killed Menelaus?

HectorIn the Warner Bros. movie “Troy,” Menelaus is the feeble, old husband of Helen, the ruler of Sparta, and the brother of Agamemnon, head king of all the Greeks. Paris seeks Menelaus for hand-to-hand combat for the hand of Helen. After Paris is injured, Hector kills Menelaus rather than let Menelaus kill his brother.

Is Troy a true story?

Most historians now agree that ancient Troy was to be found at Hisarlik. Troy was real. Evidence of fire, and the discovery of a small number of arrowheads in the archaeological layer of Hisarlik that corresponds in date to the period of Homer’s Trojan War, may even hint at warfare.

Who won Trojan War?

GreeksThe Greeks won the Trojan War, with a strategy that has become legendary. After fighting for many years, the Greeks made it look like they were…

Is Helen responsible for the Trojan War?

While Helen repeatedly acknowledges her role in igniting the conflict, other characters, such as Priam, refuse to blame her. The Greek gods – who are accused of staging this great conflict – and the Trojan prince Paris are also held responsible.

How did Helen of Troy died?

According to a variant of the story, Helen, in widowhood, was driven out by her stepsons and fled to Rhodes, where she was hanged by the Rhodian queen Polyxo in revenge for the death of her husband, Tlepolemus, in the Trojan War.

Why was Paris of Troy cursed?

Paris, also called Alexandros (Greek: “Defender”), in Greek legend, son of King Priam of Troy and his wife, Hecuba. A dream regarding his birth was interpreted as an evil portent, and he was consequently expelled from his family as an infant. … After his identity was revealed, he was received home again by Priam.

Did Paris survive the Trojan War?

He is an important person in the Trojan War, and Homer’s Iliad. Alexandros (Paris) was the son of King Priam of Troy and his wife Hecuba. … During the war, Paris killed Achilles by shooting his heel with a poisoned arrow. Late in the war, Paris was killed by Philoctetes.

Why does Helen say she left with Paris?

Aphrodite cast a spell on her. Paris seduced her with outlandish promises. … She didn’t feel that Menelaus appreciated her.

What sin did Helen of Troy commit?

The ancients thought Helen’s crime was the crime of a god, or rather a goddess, Aphrodite (in that Helen’s excessive sexual charisma was a gift of Aphrodite) – but through the medieval and Early Modern periods – in fact up until the 21st century, her affair was judged a sin against God himself.

What side was Helen on in the Trojan War?

Helping Troy Nine years into the war, but early in the story, King Priam, Paris’ father, has Helen up on the Trojan wall with him. He asks her about who important-looking soldiers are on the Achaean side.

Did Helen and Paris have a child?

But one ancient commentator says that Helen had two kids: “Hermione and her youngest-born, Nicostratus, a scion of Ares.” Pseudo-Apollodorus confirms, “Now Menelaus had by Helen a daughter Hermione and, according to some, a son Nicostratus.” A later commentator suggests Helen and Menelaus had another little boy, …

Who shot the arrow that killed Achilles?

prince ParisAchilles is killed by an arrow, shot by the Trojan prince Paris. In most versions of the story, the god Apollo is said to have guided the arrow into his vulnerable spot, his heel. In one version of the myth Achilles is scaling the walls of Troy and about to sack the city when he is shot.

Is Helen of Troy real history?

In Greek mythology, Helen of Troy is a character in Homer’s epic poem, the Iliad. … However, there is no solid evidence to suggest that Helen was a real person. The first written record of Helen is in the Iliad but the origins of the myth that surrounds her dates back to the Bronze Age.

Does Menelaus kill Helen?

During the sack of Troy, Menelaus killed Deiphobus, who had married Helen after the death of Paris. … Menelaus resolved to kill Helen, but her irresistible beauty prompted him to drop his sword and take her back to his ship “to punish her at Sparta”, as he claimed.